|  | VATICAN NORMS GOVERNING 
      GRAVE OFFENSES, INCLUDING SEXUAL ABUSE OF MINORS 
 [This translation of “"Normae de gravioribus delictis Congregationi 
      pro Doctrina Fidei reservatis” was posted by the National Catholic 
      Reporter on November 22, 2002 at
 http://www.natcath.org/NCR_Online/documents/CDFnorms.htm. The Latin text 
      is not publicly available. These Norms are an attachment to the apostolic 
      letter Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela, but when that letter was published 
      (in Latin) in Acta Apostolicae Sedis on November 5, 2001, the Norms were 
      not published with the letter.]
 The following is an unofficial English translation from the original 
        Latin.
 PART ONE
 SUBSTANTIVE NORMS
 
 Art. 1
 
 §1. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, according to 
        the norm of art. 52 of the Apostolic Constitution Pastor Bonus (6), examines 
        the more grave delicts committed both against morals and in the celebration 
        of the sacraments and, where it has done this work, proceeds to the declaration 
        or dispensation of canonical sanctions according to the norm of both common 
        and proper law, with due regard for the competence of the Apostolic Penitentiary(7) 
        and in keeping with Agendi ratio in doctrinarum examine.(8)
 
 §2. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith examines the delicts 
        spoken of in §1 according to the norms which follow.
 
 Art. 2
 
 §1. The delicts against the sanctity of the Most Holy Eucharistic 
        Sacrifice and Sacrament reserved for examination by the Congregation for 
        the Doctrine of the Faith are:
 
 1° the taking or retaining for a sacrilegious purpose, or the throwing 
        away of the consecrated species (9) spoken of in can.1367 of the Code 
        of Canon Law (10) and in can. 1442 of the Code of Canons of the Eastern 
        Churches;(11)
 
 2° attempting the liturgical action of the Eucharistic Sacrifice spoken 
        of in can. 1378, §2, no.1, of the Code of Canon Law, (12) sacerdotal 
        order…or the simulation of the same, spoken of in can.1379 of the 
        Code of Canon Law (13) and in can.1443) of the Code of Canons of the Eastern 
        Churches;(14)
 
 3° the prohibited concelebration of the Eucharistic Sacrifice in can. 
        908 of the Code of Canon Law (15) and in can. 702 of the Code of Canons 
        of the Eastern Churches, (16) spoken of in can. 1365 of the Code of Canon 
        Law (17) and in can. 1440 of the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, 
        (18) with ministers of ecclesial communities, which do not have apostolic 
        succession or do not acknowledge the sacramental dignity of priestly ordination.
 
 §2. Also reserved to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith 
        is the delict which consists in the consecration for a sacrilegious purpose 
        of one matter without the other in a Eucharistic celebration, or of both 
        outside of the Eucharistic celebration. (19) One who perpetrates this 
        delict is to be punished according to the gravity of the crime, not excluding 
        dismissal or deposition.
 
 Art. 3
 
 The delicts against the sanctity of the sacrament of Penance reserved 
        to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith are:
 
 1° the absolution of an accomplice in a sin against the sixth commandment 
        of the Decalogue, spoken of in can. 1378, §1, of the Code of Canon 
        Law (20) and in can. 1457 of the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches;(21)
 
 2° solicitation to a sin against the sixth commandment of the Decalogue 
        in the act or on the occasion or in the pretext of confession spoken of 
        in can. 1387 of the Code of Canon Law (22) and in can. 1458 of the Code 
        of Canons of the Eastern Churches, (23) if it is directed to sinning with 
        the confessor himself.
 
 3° a direct violation of the sacramental seal, spoken of in can. 1388, 
        §1, of the Code of Canon Law (24) and in can.1456, §1 of the 
        Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches.(25)
 
 Art. 4
 
 §1. Reservation to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith 
        is also extended to the delict against the sixth commandment of the Decalogue 
        committed by a cleric with a minor below the age of eighteen years.
 
 §2. One who perpetrates the delict spoken of in 1 is to be punished 
        for the gravity of the offense not excluding dismissal or deposition.
 
 Art. 5
 
 §1. A criminal action for delicts reserved to the Congregation for 
        the Doctrine of the Faith is extinguished by a prescription of ten years. 
        (26)
 
 §2. Prescription runs according to the norm of can. 1362, §2, 
        of the Code of Canon Law and can. 1152, §3, of the Code of Canons 
        of the Eastern Churches. (27) In the delict however spoken of in art. 
        4, §1, prescription begins to run from the day on which a minor reaches 
        the eighteenth year of age.
 
 PART TWO
 PROCEDURAL NORMS
 
 Title I
 The Constitution and Competence of the Tribunal
 
 Art. 6
 
 §1. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith is the Supreme 
        Apostolic Tribunal for the Latin Church and also for the Eastern Catholic 
        Churches for examining the delicts defined in the preceding articles.
 
 §2. This Supreme Tribunal examines also other delicts of which a 
        defendant is accused by the Promoter of Justice by reason of connection 
        of persons and complicity.
 
 §3. The sentences of this Supreme Tribunal, rendered within the limits 
        of its proper competence, are not subject to the approval of the Supreme 
        Pontiff.
 
 Art. 7
 
 §1. The Judges of this Supreme Tribunal are by the law itself the 
        Fathers of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
 
 §2. The Prefect of the Congregation presides as first among equals 
        over the college of the Fathers, and if the office of Prefect is vacant 
        or if the Prefect himself is impeded, the Secretary of the Congregation 
        carries out his duties.
 
 §3. It is the responsibility of the Prefect of the Congregation to 
        nominate stable or deputed judges.
 
 Art. 8
 
 It is necessary that nominated judges be priests, of mature age, possessed 
        of a doctorate in canon law, endowed with good morals, prudence and an 
        expertise in the law, even though they may simultaneously exercise a judicial 
        or consultative function before another Dicastery of the Roman Curia.
 
 Art. 9
 
 To present or sustain an accusation a Promoter of Justice is to be constituted, 
        who is to be a priest, possessed of a doctorate in canon law, endowed 
        with good morals, prudence and an expertise in the law, who may carry 
        out his office in all grades of judgement.
 
 Art. 10
 
 For the work of Notary and Chancellor, priests are appointed, either Officials 
        of this Congregation or external.
 
 Art. 11
 
 A priest, possessed of a doctorate in canon law and who is approved by 
        the Presiding Judge of the college, functions in the role of Advocate 
        or Procurator.
 
 Art. 12
 
 In other Tribunals, however, in cases involving these norms, only priests 
        can validly carry out the functions of Judge, Promoter of Justice, Notary, 
        and Patron.
 
 Art. 13
 
 As often as the Ordinary or Hierarch has at least probable knowledge of 
        a reserved delict, once the preliminary investigation has been undertaken, 
        he is to transmit this to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith 
        which, unless it calls the case to itself due to particular associated 
        conditions, will order the Ordinary or Hierarch to proceed to a conclusion, 
        with due regard, nevertheless, for the right of appealing against a sentence 
        of the first grade to the Supreme Tribunal of this same Congregation.
 
 Art. 14
 
 If a case is referred directly to the Congregation, once the preliminary 
        investigation has been undertaken, the preliminary works of the process, 
        which fall by common law to the Ordinary or Hierarch, are carried out 
        by the Congregation itself.
 
 Art. 15
 
 With due regard for the right of the Ordinary of imposing that which is 
        stated in can. 1722 of the Code of Canon Law (28) or in can. 1473 of the 
        Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, (29) the Presiding Judge of the 
        Tribunal for the turnus, at the insistence of the Promoter of Justice, 
        has the same power under the same conditions determined in the canons 
        themselves.
 
 Art. 16
 
 The Supreme Tribunal of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith 
        judges in second instance:
 
 1° cases adjudicated in first instance by inferior tribunals;
 
 2° cases defined by this same Supreme Apostolic Tribunal in first 
        instance.
 
 Title II
 The Order of Adjudication
 
 Art. 17
 
 The more grave delicts reserved to the Congregation for the Doctrine of 
        the Faith must only be pursued in a judicial process.
 
 Art. 18
 
 The Prefect is to constitute a Turnus of three or five judges to examine 
        the case.
 
 Art. 19
 
 If at the appellate level the Promoter of Justice brings forward a specifically 
        different accusation, this Supreme Tribunal can admit it and judge it 
        as in first instance.
 
 Art. 20
 
 §1. In cases concerning the delicts spoken of in art. 3, the Tribunal 
        cannot indicate the name of the accuser to either the accused or his Patron 
        unless the accuser expressly consents.
 
 §2. This same Tribunal must consider the particular issue concerning 
        the credibility of the accuser.
 
 §3. Nevertheless, it must always be observed that any danger of violating 
        the seal of the sacrament be altogether avoided.
 
 Art. 21
 
 If an incidental question arises, the College is to decide the matter 
        by decree most expeditiously.
 
 Art. 22
 
 §1. With due regard of the right to appeal to this Supreme Tribunal, 
        once an instance has been completed in some manner before another Tribunal, 
        all of the acts of the case are to be transmitted to the Congregation 
        for the Doctrine of the Faith ex officio at once.
 
 §2. The right of challenging a sentence falls to the Promoter of 
        Justice of the Congregation from the day on which the sentence from first 
        instance is made known to this same Promoter.
 
 Art. 23
 
 A res iudicata occurs:
 1° if a sentence has been rendered in second instance;
 2° if an appeal against a sentence has not been proposed within a 
        month;
 3° if, in the appellate grade, the instance is abated or is renounced;
 4° if the sentence has been rendered in accord with the norm of art. 
        16.
 
 Art. 24
 
 §1. Judicial expenses are resolved as the sentence has determined.
 
 §2. If the defendant is not able to resolve the expenses, they are 
        to be resolved by the Ordinary or Hierarch of the case.
 
 Art. 25
 
 §1. Cases of this nature are subject to pontifical secrecy. (30)
 
 §2. Whoever has violated the secrecy, whether by malice (ex dolo) 
        or through grave negligence, and causes some harm to the accused or to 
        the witnesses, is to be punished with an appropriate penalty by the higher 
        Turnus at the insistence of the injured party or even ex officio.
 
 Art. 26
 
 In these cases, together with the prescripts of these norms, to which 
        all Tribunals of the Latin Church and Eastern Catholic Churches are bound, 
        the canons concerning delicts and penalties and also the canons concerning 
        the penal process of each Code must be applied.
 
 Notes
 
 (6) POPE JOHN PAUL II, Apostolic Constitution on the Roman Curia Pastor 
        Bonus, June 28, 1988, art. 52, in AAS 80 (1988) 874: “The Congregation 
        examines offenses against the faith and more serious ones both against 
        morals or in the celebration of the sacraments which have been reported 
        to it and, if need be, proceeds to the declaration or imposition of canonical 
        sanctions in accordance with the norms of common or proper law.”
 
 (7) POPE JOHN PAUL II, Apostolic Constitution on the Roman Curia Pastor 
        Bonus, June 28, 1988, art. 118, in AAS 80 (1988) 890: “For the internal 
        forum, whether sacramental or non-sacramental, it grants absolutions, 
        dispensation, commutations, validations, condonations and other favors.”
 
 (8) CONGREGATION FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH, Agendi ratio in doctrinarum 
        examine, June 29, 1997, in AAS 89 (1997) 830-835.
 
 (9) PONTIFICAL COUNCIL FOR THE INTERPRETATION OF LEGISLATIVE TEXTS, Response 
        to a proposed doubt, June 4, 1999, in AAS 91 (1999) 918:
 D. Whether or not the word “abicere” in canons 1367 CIC and 
        1442 CCEO should be understood only as the act of throwing away.
 R. Negative and ad mentem.
 The “mind” is that the word “abicere” should be 
        considered to include any voluntarily and gravely contemptuous action 
        towards the Sacred Species.
 
 (10) Code of Canon Law, can. 1367 - A person who throws away the consecrated 
        species or takes or retains them for a sacrilegious purpose incurs a latae 
        sententiae excommunication reserved to the Apostolic See; moreover, a 
        cleric can be punished with another penalty, not excluding dismissal from 
        the clerical state.
 
 (11) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1442 - A person who 
        has thrown away the Divine Eucharist or taken or retained it for a sacrilegious 
        purpose is to be punished with a major excommunication and, if a cleric, 
        also with other penalties not excluding deposition.
 
 (12) Code of Canon Law, can. 1378-§2. The following incur a latae 
        sententiae penalty of interdict or, if a cleric, a latae sententiae penalty 
        of suspension:
 1° a person who attempts the liturgical action of the Eucharistic 
        sacrifice though not promoted to the …
 
 (13) Code of Canon Law, can. 1379-In addition to the cases mentioned in 
        can. 1378, a person who simulates the administration of a sacrament is 
        to be punished with a just penalty.
 
 (14) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1443 - A person who 
        has simulated the celebration of the Divine Liturgy or other sacraments 
        is to be punished with an appropriate penalty, not excluding a major excommunication.
 
 (15) Code of Canon Law, can. 908 - Catholic priests are forbidden to concelebrate 
        the Eucharist with priests or ministers of churches or ecclesial communities 
        which do not have full communion with the Catholic church.
 
 (16) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 702 - Catholic priests 
        are forbidden to concelebrate the Divine Liturgy with non-Catholic priests 
        or ministers.
 
 (17) Code of Canon Law, can. 1365 - A person guilty of prohibited participation 
        in sacred rites (communicatio in sacris) is to be punished with a just 
        penalty.
 
 (18) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1440-A person who violates 
        the norms of law concerning participation in sacred rites (communicatio 
        in sacris) can be punished with an appropriate penalty.
 
 (19) Code of Canon Law, can. 927 - It is absolutely forbidden, even in 
        extreme urgent necessity, to consecrate one matter without the other or 
        even both outside the eucharistic celebration.
 
 (20) Code of Canon Law, can. 1378-§1. A priest who acts against the 
        prescript of can. 977 incurs a latae sententiae excommunication reserved 
        to the Apostolic See.
 
 (21) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1457-A priest who has 
        absolved an accomplice in a sin against chastity is to be punished with 
        a major excommunication, with due regard for canon 728, §1, n.2.
 
 (22) Code of Canon Law, can. 1387-A priest who in the act, on the occasion, 
        or under the pretext of confession solicits a penitent to sin against 
        the sixth commandment of the Decalogue is to be punished, according to 
        the gravity of the delict, by suspension, prohibitions, and privations; 
        in graver cases he is to be dismissed from the clerical state.
 
 (23) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1458-A priest who in 
        the act, on the occasion, or under the pretext of confession, has solicited 
        a penitent to sin against chastity, is to be punished with an appropriate 
        penalty, not excluding deposition.
 
 (24) Code of Canon Law, canon 1388-§1. A confessor who directly violates 
        the sacramental seal incurs a latae sententiae excommunication reserved 
        to the Apostolic See; one who does so only indirectly is to be punished 
        according to the gravity of the delict.
 
 (25) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1456-§1. A confessor 
        who has directly violated the sacramental seal is to be punished with 
        a major excommunication, with due regard for canon 728, §1, n.1; 
        however, if he broke this deal in another manner, he is to be punished 
        with an appropriate penalty.
 
 (26) Code of Canon Law, can 1362-§1. Prescription extinguishes a 
        criminal action after three years unless it concerns:
 1° delicts reserved to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith…
 
 (27) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1152-§2. A penal 
        action is extinguished by prescription after three years, unless it is 
        a question of:
 1° delicts reserved to the Apostolic See…
 
 (28) Code of Canon Law, can. 1722 - To prevent scandals, to protect the 
        freedom of witnesses, and to guard the course of justice, the ordinary, 
        after having heard the promoter of justice and cited the accused, at any 
        stage of the process can exclude the accused from the sacred ministry 
        or from some office and ecclesiastical function, can impose or forbid 
        residence in some place or territory, or even can prohibit public participation 
        in the Most Holy Eucharist. Once the cause ceases, all these measures 
        must be revoked; they also end by the law itself when the penal process 
        ceases.
 
 (29) Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, can. 1473 - To prevent scandals, 
        to protect the freedom of witnesses, and to guard the course of justice, 
        the hierarch, after having heard the promoter of justice and cited the 
        accused, at any stage and grade of the penal trial can exclude the accused 
        from the exercise of sacred orders, an office, a ministry, or another 
        function, can impose or forbid residence in some place or territory, or 
        even can prohibit public reception of the Divine Eucharist. Once the cause 
        ceases, all these measures must be revoked and they will end by the law 
        itself when the penal trial ceases.
 
 (30) SECRETARY OF STATE, Rescript from an Audience of the Holy Father, 
        “The February 4,” by which the general Ordering of the Roman 
        Curia is set forth, April 30, 1999, “The General Regulations of 
        the Roman Curia,” April 30, 1999, art. 36 §2, in AAS 91(1999)646: 
        “With particular care, pontifical secrecy will be observed, according 
        the norm of the Instruction Secreta continere of February 4, 1974.”
 THE PAPAL SECRETARY OF STATE, Rescript from an Audience, the Instruction 
        Secreta continere, Concerning Pontifical Secrecy, February 4, 1974, in 
        AAS 66 (1974) 89-92:
 “Art. 1. Included under pontifical secrecy are:…
 4. Extrajudicial denunciations received regarding delicts against faith 
        and against morals, and regarding delicts perpetrated against the sacrament 
        of Penance. Likewise the process and decision which pertain to those denunciations, 
        always safeguarding the right of one who has been reported to authorities 
        to know of the denunciation if such knowledge is necessary for his own 
        defense. However, it will be permissible to make known the name of the 
        denouncer then only when authorities think it opportune that the denounced 
        and the denouncer come face to face;…”(p.90)
 |  |